The Movie Waffler New Release Review - BUDDY | The Movie Waffler

New Release Review - BUDDY

Buddy review
A mother enters the nightmare realm of TV children's show Buddy in search of her daughter.

Review by Eric Hillis

Directed by: Casper Kelly

Starring: Cristin Milioti, Keegan-Michael Key, Delaney Quinn, Patton Oswalt, Michael Shannon, Topher Grace

Buddy poster

The idea of a children's entertainer secretly being a force for evil should be played out at this point (do we really need any more movies about killer clowns?). It's a quarter of a century since Robin Williams channelled the ickiness of Barney in Danny DeVito's Death to Smoochy, so isn't Buddy a little late to the game?

Well, theoretically yes, but director Casper Kelly seems to have more on his mind here than simply regurgitating an old joke about the creepiness of popular children's entertainers. Buddy works because Kelly, who broke out with his cult viral short Too Many Cooks over a decade ago, plays the ridiculous premise with a straight face. It begins as a satire and gradually becomes as unhinged as a Nightmare on Elm Street movie, just with more primary colours.

Buddy review

The film imagines that a '90s children's show, "It's Buddy," actually exists in its own world ruled over by the tyrannical Buddy, a giant orange unicorn voiced by Keegan Michael Key and physically performed by puppeteer Sergey Zhuravsky. Just like Barney, Buddy hangs out with a bunch of young kids and teaches them about life through simple-minded songs. He arranges tasks for them like attending a dance party and cleaning the clubhouse. When one kid decides he has enough of such forced fun, the brat goes missing, prompting suspicion in Freddy (Delaney Quinn), who tries to warn the other kids that Buddy is a wrong 'un.


Meanwhile in the real world, suburban mum Grace (Cristin Milioti) suddenly becomes consumed with the idea that she had a daughter who is no longer part of her family. This drives a wedge in her marriage to the insensitive Ben (Topher Grace), who is convinced his wife has gone nuts.

Buddy review

The two timelines will ultimately converge via Buddy's ability to kidnap children from the real world by reverse-Ringu-ing them through their TV sets into his domain.


Kelly and co-writer Jamie King strike the right balance between horror and satire to ensure this silly premise gets under our skin in unexpected ways. The initial bang on recreations of late 20th century kids TV are filled with laughs, but as the narrative becomes darker those laughs become more uncomfortable. There is something especially chilling about horror movies in which children find that the adult figures they previously riled on can no longer be trusted, and Buddy leans into this to great effect. There is a nod to Night of the Hunter in one beautifully mounted sequence, and while the moment is played to generate chuckles from cinephiles, it draws a line between Robert Mitchum's preacher and Buddy the entertainer, two adult figures children are expected to be able to trust.

Buddy review

In the real world sequences, Milioti goes all in on her portrayal of a woman discovering she's being gaslit by some unseen malevolent force. The idea of feeling that she is missing a child that doesn't exist proves profoundly unsettling, adding an extra layer of poignancy I didn't expect from a movie about a murderous Barney knockoff. Buddy is by no means the one joke horror comedy its simple premise suggests.

Buddy is in UK/ROI cinemas from November 27th.

2026 movie reviews