
Review by Eric Hillis
Directed by: Paloma Schneideman
Starring: Ani Palmer, Rain Spencer, Noah Taylor

Musician turned writer/director Paloma Schneideman's feature debut Big Girls Don't Cry is less a coming of age story and more a loss of innocence tale. It is set over that one pivotal summer in every teenager's life when they no longer feel like a child but aren't yet prepared for the messiness of adulthood. That summer here is in New Zealand, with Christmas decorations blasted by the southern hemisphere sun, gives it a unique flavour.

It's 2006 and 14-year-old Sid (Ani Palmer) is desperate to become an adult over her summer/Christmas break. That will probably involve "hooking up" with a boy, even though Sid is finding herself increasingly drawn to her own sex (while masturbating to a poster of Tupac, her gaze moves across to the scantily clad female model posing next to the rapper). Outgrowing her best friend Tia (Ngataitangirua Hita), Sid awkwardly ingratiates herself with the slightly older Lana (Beatrix Rain Wolfe) by stealing from her dad's booze supply. Sid is immediately thrust into a world of late night beach parties, hanging out with Lana and her friends, which includes a trio of creepy older boys who know just how to pull the strings of naive younger girls.
Sid is less interested in these boys than in Freya (Rain Spencer), the Lea Seydoux lookalike American exchange student her older sister Adele (Tara Canton) has brought home for the holidays. With Adele stepping up to take the place of Sid's absent mother, she hasn't been a big sister in some time, and now Freya steps in to fill to that void, introducing Sid to make-up and weed.

In what should be a star-making turn, Palmer is a revelation. Schneideman has written the character as a complex mess of conflicting emotions, and Palmer conveys this with sensitivity. She gives the impression that Sid is always the smartest person in the room, but that isn't always an advantage. While we like Sid, we can understand how she can make others feel uncomfortable, and Schneideman dares to make her young protagonist not entirely easy to empathise with. Sid does some pretty awful things here, like dropping Tia for the "cooler" kids, constantly demeaning her admittedly rather useless father (Noah Taylor, excellent as a man who has all but given up on life), and posing online as Tia's older brother to coax Lana into sending her intimate selfies. It says a lot about Palmer's charisma that despite all this, we can still see through the bravado and acknowledge the scared little girl in Sid.
Everything about Big Girls Don't Cry feels authentic, and it is clearly the product of a filmmaker channelling and reckoning with their own childhood. There is great use of production and costume design to contrast the difference between the working class Sid's chaotic life (her messy home is clearly devoid of a mother's influence) and the superficiality of her new middle class friends with their well put together outfits and gleaming homes (the lawns of which Sid's father makes a living mowing).

Big Girls Don't Cry is ultimately about a young girl discovering that she doesn't fit in, the barriers of class and sexuality she couldn't previously see now all too visibly blocking her path. In the end, Sid retreats back into her working class world, giving her old man a break and attempting to reconnect with Tia. But it is no happy ending, no trite "there's no place like home" message tacked on here. We come away feeling like Sid will have to make a few more mistakes before she truly finds herself, that her community, and maybe even her country, is too small to contain her.

Big Girls Don't Cry is in UK/ROI cinemas from November 27th.
