The Movie Waffler New Release Review - A TALENT FOR MURDER | The Movie Waffler

New Release Review - A TALENT FOR MURDER

A Talent for Murder review
A young man attempts to convince Patricia Highsmith to pen another novel, by any means necessary.

Review by Eric Hillis

Directed by: Anton Corbijn

Starring: Helen Mirren, Alden Ehrenreich, Olivia Cooke, Juliet Stevenson

A Talent for Murder poster

The movies love to portray aging writers as cantankerous old coots. Patricia Highsmith would seem a perfect fit then, given her notoriously misanthropic persona. Director Anton Corbijn's A Talent for Murder sees Helen Mirren play Highsmith, but this is no biopic. Adapted from screenwriter Joanna Murray-Smith's 2014 play 'Switzerland', A Talent for Murder imagines a scenario in which the elderly Highsmith is a reclusive Colonel Kurtz, with a young editor sent up the river to tempt her back to civilisation.

A Talent for Murder review

That young editor is Edward (Alden Ehrenreich), who has been sent to Highsmith's adopted home of Switzerland by a New York publisher who wishes to convince the writer to pen one last instalment of her signature Tom Ripley series. The last editor sent to Highsmith's home mysteriously vanished, with rumours of a descent into madness.


Edward finds Highsmith unsurprisingly uncooperative. She is abrasive and argumentative, deliberately pushing his buttons with her vile worldviews. But Highsmith seems to recognise something primal lurking under Edward's preppy surface. She allows him to stay the night in her home, and the next day over some drinks the two begin spitballing a potential plot for a new Ripley adventure.

A Talent for Murder review

This sees Corbijn's film split in two, with Ehrenreich playing the dual roles of Edward in reality and Ripley in a recreation of the scenario Edward and Highsmith concoct on the fly. Set in Rome, the latter sees Ripley seduce a young American woman (Olivia Cooke, who also plays a woman Edward earlier met on the train) with an eye on the inheritance she will receive from her uncle. It's a rather generic murder plot, and you can't imagine Highsmith settling for something so uninspired in reality.


The trouble with A Talent for Murder is that most of the suspense comes courtesy of the fictional scenario in Edward and Highsmith's heads, so there are no real stakes. Sure, Mirren's Highsmith is a bit sinister, to say the least, but do any viewers really believe the movie is going to reimagine a revered author as a homicidal maniac? Mirren is so gleefully horrid that you wish she were playing the role in a much trashier movie, perhaps one of those tawdry thrillers of the '60s that earned the label "Hagsploitation" and gave aging female stars like Bette Davis and Joan Crawford the opportunity to reinvent themselves.

A Talent for Murder review

It's Ehrenreich who is the standout here however. As the meek Edward and the seductively dangerous Ripley he gets to demonstrate his range, equally convincing in both parts. There is a far more interesting movie bubbling under the surface here, one about an aging sociopath teaching a young apprentice how to embrace their darker instincts, but the gimmick of including a real life figure at its centre means the movie can never really spread its wings and embrace its own dark side.

A Talent for Murder is in UK/ROI cinemas from November 20th.

2026 movie reviews