
Risk is a factor in everyone’s life, although how willing we are to expose ourselves to its rewards or drawbacks varies from person to person. What unites us is our love of all-or-nothing endings in storytelling, particularly on the silver screen. Something draws us to plots that climax with characters making a choice that has a binary outcome of either glorious victory or total defeat. So, what makes this narrative tool so popular?
Losing Feels Bad
Our brains have evolved to be averse to losing something, to the extent that we’ll feel the pain of losing far more intensely than the pleasure of winning. While this is a concept that stems from economics, it applies perfectly to all-or-nothing endings in movies.
Take the end of The Italian Job, when a crew of crooks is literally teetering on a cliff edge in a coach, torn between the choice of saving themselves at the expense of seeing their stolen fortune fall into the abyss. They can live, but get nothing, or risk going for the gold, and potentially lose their lives as well. This true cliffhanger is famously left up in the air, so the audience doesn’t even get the payoff of a clear conclusion.
It’s this same energy that drives people to gamble, whether at land-based locations or via an online casino website. Every spin of the reels or roll of the dice holds that potential for glory or disaster.
Compromise is Boring
Our lives are defined by compromise, which makes sense when we’re all trying to live side by side in a society where the needs of the many must outweigh the needs of the few. But from a storytelling perspective, it’s not that exciting to have characters in a movie negotiating and being reasonable when a conflict arises. Drama lives in the heart of conflict, and movies that build towards explosive finallies, whether figurative or literal, are fundamentally more engaging.
Imagine if Die Hard didn’t end with Detective John McClane approaching the villains, apparently unarmed, gambling that the two remaining shots in his pistol, tapped to his back, will be enough to deal with the remaining bad guys and save his wife. We could have McClane instead negotiating with Hans Gruber and agreeing to let him go in exchange for his wife’s safe return. It’s more realistic, but also much blander.
The End is Everything
All good movies result in audiences leaving the theater talking to each other about what they just saw, inciting discussions that continue long into the night, and beyond. And what defines how we feel about a movie is often crystallized in the final moments.
In other words, an all-or-nothing ending can give the audience a better impression of a film that, up until the ending, was only so-so. It’s why every movie in the Fast & Furious franchise climaxes with a completely over-the-top action set piece, as well as often opening with one. Bookending a film with risky, adrenaline-inducing action keeps audiences happy and helps them look over the creakier parts of the story and production.