The Movie Waffler Tribeca Film Festival 2026 Review - CROOKS | The Movie Waffler

Tribeca Film Festival 2026 Review - CROOKS

Crooks review
After stealing from the mob and chased by a hitman, a woman takes refuge in a remote diner.

Review by Eric Hillis

Directed by: Mickey Keating

Starring: Angela Trimbur, Chase Williamson, Melora Walters, Keith Kupferer

Crooks poster

Writer/director Mickey Keating is known for making films that wear their influences proudly on their sleeves. Darling is Keating's take on Roman Polanski's "Apartment Trilogy." Carnage Park owes much to Peter Watkins' Punishment Park. His best film, Offseason, is essentially a reworking of the cult '70s horror masterpiece Messiah of Evil. His latest, Crooks, is a love letter to Film Noir that eventually takes a left turn into a Psycho homage.

The nod to Noir is explicit in the film's early scenes. Shot in silvery black and white, they have the look of Robert Rodriguez's Sin City adaptations, taking us into an alternate world that seems to exist at some uncertain point between the 1940s and the present. We're introduced immediately to a classic Noir archetype, the sultry nightclub singer, in Faye (Angela Trimbur). On the very night she loses her job for standing up to a rowdy drunk, Faye's ex-boyfriend and former stick-up partner Johnny (Chase Williamson) re-enters her life with a proposition. He plans to hold up a lucrative poker game run by a mobster, and wants Faye to help him out.

Crooks review

The resulting fallout of the robbery sees Faye fleeing with the loot across the MidWest, pursued by a violent hitman known as "the Fixer" (Keith Kupferer). The Fixer has decided to go rogue and wants the loot for himself, and he'll happily kill anyone who gets in the way.


The Psycho influence emerges when Faye seeks refuge at a remote diner that doesn't see much business since the highway closed. It's staffed solely by Blanche (Melora Walters), a nervy waitress who appears to be hiding a secret.

You can view Crooks either as a derivative cobbling together of various influences or a fun pastiche of classic genre cinema. You'd be right in both cases. Initially Keating's film is so obvious in its homages that we fear we're in for a movie that can't stand on its own. It's not until Faye arrives at the diner that the movie develops its own personality, at which point it becomes an intriguing two-hander. Walters and Trimbur have a prickly chemistry as the two women metaphorically circle each other like a pair of suspicious cats. There is an almost homoerotic frisson between the two women. They've both been bad girls, and they just might get a little badder.

Crooks review

The monochrome of the early urban scenes gives way to full colour when Faye hits the open road. The credits list two cinematographers - Mac Fisken and Edgar T. Gómez - and I assume one was responsible for the black and white scenes while the other handled the colour portions. Regardless, there is a clear visual distinction between the two segments of Keating's movie. Beginning in familiar Noir territory, Crooks segues into something closer to '70s grindhouse fare, with a splash of Italian crime thrillers for good measure.

There is practically nothing original about Crooks' plot, but Keating paradoxically has a style of his own, and his latest movie's climax is a beautifully constructed stalking sequence in an open field. By that point we're watching a completely different picture to the one that unspooled 70 minutes earlier. This is less a work of originality and more a filmmaker using narrative cinema to take us on a journey through some of his favourite cult movies.


2026 movie reviews